Cayey FL Homes For Sale

Finca Quebrada Arriba Cayey SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Prime investment and land development opportunity in Cayey, Puerto Rico! This expansive 28.59-cuerda parcel (approx. 27.78 acres / 112,401 sq. meters) is located in the scenic Quebrada Arriba Ward along State Road 15 Km 21.0. Zoned B-Q (Forests), the property is ideal for agricultural use, recreational facilities, horse stables, or building a private single-family retreat surrounded by nature. Featuring lush tropical vegetation, varied rural topography, and direct frontage on a paved state road, it offers complete privacy and endless potential. Water and electricity connections are available at the main road. Sold "As-Is". Contact us for more details!

Carr 15 Km 21, Cayey

$165,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Urbanización Reparto Montellano SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Located in Urb. Reparto Montellano, in a highly central area of Cayey, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home sits on an approximately 340 m² lot. The residence is ready to occupy, with a practical layout, bright interior spaces, a functional kitchen and a generous yard. Its central location provides convenient access to shopping, services and Cayey’s main roads.

Reparto Montellano Calle B I-92, Cayey

$985,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Bo. Lapa Carr 1 Cayey Pr. SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

COUNTRY LIVING AT ITS BEST IN CAYEY! WITH A RIVER!! Discover this beautiful and unique property in Barrio Lapa, Cayey, offering approximately 2 acres of land in a peaceful rural setting, outside the flood zone. Surrounded by nature and lush vegetation, the property features plantain trees, fruit trees, and a variety of other plantings, creating an ideal setting for those who appreciate agriculture, gardening, and the tranquility of the countryside. The property includes a recently constructed four-bedroom (3 beds and a loft), four baths (2 in the primary residence -and-a-half-bath(unfinished but all the items are there) and the other 2 in the wood residence.This home designed to take full advantage of its spectacular surroundings. The abundance of glass throughout the home provides beautiful panoramic views and fills the interior with natural light, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere. The property also features a newly built wooden house currently being used as an Airbnb, offering an excellent opportunity for additional rental income, guest accommodations, or a private retreat. An additional structure on the property provides even more versatility and can be transformed into a private gym, home theater/cinema, entertainment area, studio, or other recreational space, depending on the new owner's needs. With approximately 2 acres of land, mature vegetation, agricultural potential, multiple structures, breathtaking views, and a peaceful country atmosphere, this property offers a rare opportunity to enjoy the best of rural living while having the potential for income-producing and recreational uses. A truly special property where nature, comfort, privacy, and investment potential come together.

CARR 1 Ruta 715km 3.5 Lote 3, Cayey

$575,000

00736 Zip Code

Commercial property consisting of approximately 3,200 square feet located in Cayey. Former supermarket offering flexible layout for retail, restaurant, wholesale, medical, office or warehouse use. Sale includes the real estate and existing equipment. Excellent opportunity for owner-users or investors seeking to reposition a commercial asset. Easy access and strong redevelopment potential.

PR 14 Barrio Maton, Cayey

$1,041,000

00737 Zip Code

Commercial Opportunity in Cayey Two-story commercial property with excellent visibility from PR-52 and convenient access from Exit #39 (San Juan–Cayey direction). Its strategic location makes it an outstanding opportunity to establish, expand, or relocate your business. The property offers approximately 6,079 square feet of building area on a 4,766-square-meter lot, providing ample space for parking, future expansion, or additional improvements. It also includes a leased billboard that generates rental income for the owner, adding immediate investment value. Originally designed as an educational facility, the layout includes multiple classrooms, offices, a reception area, kitchen, laundry area, bathrooms, and dormitory-style rooms. Each classroom has its own private exterior entrance while maintaining interior access, offering exceptional flexibility for a wide variety of commercial uses. Ideal for educational institutions, professional offices, medical or therapy centers, daycare facilities, nonprofit organizations, training centers, assisted living facilities, or any business requiring generous space and outstanding visibility. A property that combines a strategic location, versatile layout, development potential, and an additional income-producing asset. Schedule your private tour today. The sale price was established based on an appraisal.

Marginal PR-52 Barrio Montellanos, Sector Pepe Hoyos, Cayey

$1,500

00736 Zip Code

Spacious Land Available for Lease! For lease: 2,473.07 square meters of land, fully fenced, offering a spacious, private, and clearly defined area suitable for a variety of potential uses, subject to applicable zoning regulations and permits. An excellent opportunity for those seeking ample land with the potential to establish or expand their operations.

Carr 738 KM 1.4 Bo Montellano, Cayey

$290,000

Barrio Pueblo SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Turnkey mixed-use investment opportunity in the heart of Downtown Cayey! Beautifully remodeled with an attractive façade, this well-maintained property has a proven history of stable occupancy and offers an excellent opportunity for investors seeking immediate cash flow and long-term value. The first floor features approximately 956 SF of commercial space, currently occupied by an established accounting office, and includes a reception area, conference room, private office, restroom, and storage room. The second floor offers approximately 939 SF of residential living space with 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, kitchen, and dining area. Constructed in concrete and zoned Commercial Intermediate (C-I), the property features separate entrances for both units, 2 electric meters and 1 water meter, and both units are currently leased. Ideally located in the heart of Cayey, just minutes from the University of Puerto Rico at Cayey, shopping centers, restaurants, banks, government offices, and with convenient access to major highways. A rare opportunity to own a well-maintained income-producing property in one of Cayey’s most established commercial corridors.

152 C. Núñez Romero Unit 152, Cayey

$1,100,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Guavate SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

AT THE TOP OF THE WORLD | GUAVATE MOUNTAIN RETREAT Set at the crown of a mountaintop in Guavate, Cayey, this peaceful refuge feels suspended above the landscape, with sweeping views of the surrounding mountains in every direction. A small winding road leads past a few neighboring residences to the property gate; from there, the path continues upward until the home reveals itself at what feels like the top of the world. The architecture has a tropical modernist undertone, with exposed concrete, practical lines, and wide outdoor spaces designed to let the landscape take center stage. The main residence opens to a generous wraparound veranda and expansive terrace with a pool table and bar area, all oriented toward the views. Inside, the ground level features a dramatic foyer with tall ceilings, an open kitchen, and living and dining areas that flow directly to the terrace, anchored by a working chimney! A rare and atmospheric feature in Puerto Rico, especially meaningful in the cooler mountain months of Cayey. Two bedrooms share a full bathroom on this level, while the entire second floor is dedicated to the primary suite, complete with an oversized walk-in closet, ensuite bathroom, and private covered balcony overlooking the landscape. Surrounded by blooming robles nativos with their lilac-pink flowers, towering red torch ginger, giant ferns and layered tropical foliage, the property feels both elemental and transportive, a place where mountain air and endless green meet in perfect balance. A round dipping pool is perfectly positioned to capture the views, while a separate guest cabaña offers two independent suites, each with their own kitchen and bathroom, separated by a lock-off door for flexibility and privacy. The property is fully supported by a whole-property backup generator and its own private water source with cistern and pump system, an exceptional advantage in today’s climate of water rationing and drought. Private, resilient, and deeply connected to the mountain landscape, this Guavate mountain retreat feels worlds away while remaining unmistakably Puerto Rico.

PR-184 Guavate, Cayey

$595,000

Urb. Valle Alto SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

This prime land parcel is located at 442 Jose De Diego Avenue, Valle Alto Urbanization, in the municipality of Cayey, PR. The property spans a total area of 6.46 cuerdas. It features a versatile topography within an urban setting, positioned extremely close to the town center, major shopping centers, hospitals, and the University of Puerto Rico at Cayey. The site offers rapid access to Expressway PR-52 and other main regional routes, ensuring excellent connectivity. Zoned R-I (Intermediate Residential) and classified as SU (Urban Soil), the best use for this land includes residential development, multi-family housing, or institutional projects, supported by soil compositions such as CaF and MaC. The property has a value of approximately $92,105 for each cuerda. Environmental records indicate the entire terrain is situated within Flood Zone X, placing the area outside of high-risk flood zones. This significant acreage represents a rare and high-potential investment opportunity in one of the most central and accessible locations in the mountain region. CRIM: $175.00 annually. Coordinates: 18.10911140, -66.17489839

442 Urb. Valle Alto Avenue, Cayey

$110,000

Bo. Rincón Lomas SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Land for Sale – Rincón Lomas Neighborhood, Praderas de La Plata Avenue in Cayey. Excellent opportunity to acquire land in a prime location in Cayey, located on Highway 14 Km 71.9 behind the Mennonite Hospital and the Mansiones de Monte Verde Urbanization. It has 6,180 square meters, equivalent to one and a half acres plus 284 square meters. It faces the Praderas del Plata Urbanization and is near the El Torito Urbanization. The property has easy access to the Luis A. Ferré Expressway (PR-52), allowing for quick connections to San Juan, Caguas, Salinas, and the south of the island. Strategically located near numerous services and businesses, including Walmart, Burlington, Marshalls, Chili’s, Planet Fitness, Caribbean Cinemas, banks, supermarkets, pharmacies, and restaurants. Water and electricity services are available in the area. Septic or sewer system according to applicable regulations. It is not in a flood zone and is free of liens and encumbrances. Sold "As Is". It's not for appraisal

Bo Rincón Lomas, Cayey

$115,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Bo Buena Vista SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Residence located in an accessible area, up the road from Colmado Colón, approximately 5 minutes from downtown Cayey and the town square. The property features 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, living and dining areas, kitchen, family room, additional sitting area, balcony, and laundry area. The property includes an additional structure at the rear that requires demolition; therefore, it does not qualify for housing assistance programs. The property is only eligible for FHA 203(k) financing. Don’t miss this opportunity!

Daniel Bonilla 30 Buena Vista, Cayey

$1,100,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Rd15 Km20.6 Bo.Quebrada Arriba SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Private Mountaintop Retreat in Cayey – 5 Acres with Panoramic Views Perched at approximately 1,000 meters in the central mountains of Puerto Rico, this exceptional 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom retreat sits on 5 acres of lush land, offering 120° horizon views, unmatched privacy, and an adventurous countryside lifestyle unlike any other. Accessed through a long private driveway and surrounded by nature, the property is designed for those who value freedom, outdoor living, and the tranquility of mountain life while still enjoying modern comforts. Only 10 minutes from downtown Cayey and minutes from Guavate’s renowned local culture and cuisine, this estate blends convenience with a true escape into nature. Whether it’s riding 4-wheelers through the property, caring for the animals, harvesting tropical fruit, or enjoying cool mountain air, this home offers a unique lifestyle experience ideal for outdoor enthusiasts seeking both comfort and privacy. Built for reliable full time living or remote work, the property includes Starlink high speed internet, a 10 kilowatt solar system with battery backup powering essential circuits, a gas generator, solar water heater, 600-amp main panel, reverse osmosis water filtration system, a 1,200-gallon stainless steel cistern, and a drilled 300-foot well. The interior features travertine and ceramic tile floors, PVC and quartz finishes, a spacious upstairs primary suite with custom desk and AC, and a living room also equipped with AC. The home additionally includes a gas stove, wraparound porch, security camera system, and a 1-car garage with extensive built-in shelving. Outdoor amenities include a pond, a shed with electricity and water, and licensed potential to build an additional home on the property. The grounds are rich with tropical fruit trees including tangerine, banana, guava, avocado, orange, and pana trees, along with 3 female goats that help naturally maintain the land. Offering cooler mountain temperatures, total privacy, modern infrastructure, and an authentic countryside lifestyle, this one of a kind retreat is ideal as a private residence, vacation home, or investment opportunity. Experience the beauty, adventure, and serenity of Puerto Rico’s mountains while remaining conveniently close to the city

RD15 KM20.6 Bo. Quebrada Arriba, Cayey

$395,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Bo. Cercadillo SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Located on the edge of the Bosque de Pinos in Cayey, this multi-unit property offers a private retreat with scenic valley views. The top-floor residence features a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom layout with a wrap-around balcony, totaling 1,880 square feet of space. This unit includes a primary bedroom with an ensuite bathroom and jacuzzi tub, tiled floors, louvered windows, and a versatile hallway study. The middle-floor unit, accessible at ground level from the carport, features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom with a newly renovated kitchen. This property presents a significant opportunity for multi-generational living or a versatile income-generating investment; the layout allows for living in one unit while renting the other, or utilizing the entire property as a high-capacity rental. Featuring a two-bay concrete garage with a workspace, gated entry, and established landscaping that blends into the adjacent forest, this home provides a flexible and private living arrangement.

Carretera 715 Kilometro 3.7, Cayey

$125,000

00736 Zip Code

12 acres of beautiful hill country with almost immediate access to Highway 52 towards Caguas. Electricity and septic already in place.

KM.HM 59 3 Carr 1, Bo Quebrada Arriba, Cayey

$3,000,000

00737 Zip Code

5.14-acre property, 100% flat, bordering a beautiful river, with 15 rental units. This property is located on Highway 745, Las Vegas neighborhood, Cayey. Just minutes from shopping centers, main avenues, and downtown. (See development idea photos at the end.)

743 Pr 743, Cayey

$2,995,000

00736 Zip Code

This massive estate is located at Road 7786 KM 0.5, Beatriz Ward, in the municipality of Cayey, PR (extending into Cidra). The property spans a total area of 151.22 cuerdas. It features a diverse and majestic mountainous topography, providing panoramic views and a vast natural canvas for large-scale development, ecological tourism, or a private conservation retreat. The site maintains excellent connectivity with frontage near major regional access points. Zoned with a mixed classification of R-G (General Rural) at 47 percnt, C-R (Resource Conservation) at 29 percnt, and R-I (Intermediate Residential) at 24 percnt, the land offers versatile potential for sustainable housing or agricultural projects, supported by a rich soil profile including MxF, RoC2, and MxE. The property has a value of approximately $19,805 for each cuerda. Environmental records indicate the terrain is situated almost entirely within Flood Zone X (95.7 out of 100), with minor advisory portions in Zone A and X 0.2 ACF. This significant acreage represents a premier investment opportunity in the central mountain range. Coordinates: 18.14318104, -66.12596315

7786 Bo Beatriz Km 0.5, Cayey

$325,000

Lote Maton Abajo, Cayey SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Discover the tranquility of nature with this expansive 23,177 m² lot located in the lush mountains of Cayey. Ideal for those seeking peace, privacy, and breathtaking views, this property offers endless possibilities to build the home of your dreams or a cozy guesthouse. A design concept for a primary residence or guesthouse is available, allowing you to fully envision the potential of this unique space. Enjoy a lifestyle connected to nature without sacrificing essential comforts. (Images are for illustrative purposes only. The home shown has not been built.)

INTERIOR BO MATON ABAJO Matón Abajo, Cayey

$1,495,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Jajome Alto SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Infinity pool with panoramic mountain views, this rare retreat blends luxury with nature. Nestled within 41.6 acres (31.92 acres on the main lot and 9.7 acres on two adjacent lots) of lush greenery this exquisite country estate it is a seamless harmony of nature and design. A grand stone staircase, carved into the mountainside, leads you into a home where every detail is crafted to embrace the stunning surroundings. With three bedrooms and three and a half bathrooms, the home offers both comfort and style. Expansive windows frame panoramic views, while smart-home features—including a solar power system and Sonos sound throughout—bring effortless convenience. A built-in wine cellar ensures your favorite vintages are always at hand. The master suite offers a private cinematic experience with a state-of-the-art movie theater setup—perfect for cozy nights in. Step outside to experience the magic of the outdoors: an infinity pool where the trees feel like part of the landscape, a terrace with a fireplace and grill for unforgettable gatherings, and a recently built wooden deck immersed in the forest, perfect for quiet moments in nature. Enjoy reliability with a solar power system consisting of 24 - 440W panels and 2 Tesla Powerwall II batteries. A true sanctuary where luxury meets the wild beauty of the mountains—redefining country living.

km 16.5 Pr-15, Cayey

$445,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Guavate SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Beautiful property in Guavate, Cayey, offering cool mountain weather, nature views, and a 1,482 m² lot. The home features two concrete housing units, each with its own electric meter, perfect for living in one unit and renting the other, or as an investment. The main home offers 2,921 sq ft, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a 2-car garage, excellent roof condition, and a balcony with stunning views. The second unit has 1,500 sq ft, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a private entrance. Includes perimeter fencing, open terrace, and large storage area. Great location near PR-184 with easy access to PR-52.

PR-184 KM 32.4 S Beatriz, Cayey

$45,000

Bo Beatriz SubDv. ⋅ 00736 Zip Code

Beautiful 600 m² Lot for Sale in Barrio Beatriz, Cayey Mountain Views, Breezes and Endless Potential Discover the perfect opportunity to build your dream home or investment property in the highly sought-after community of Barrio Beatriz, Cayey. This 600 m² (6,458 sq. ft. / 0.14 acres) parcel offers breathtaking panoramic views of Puerto Rico’s lush mountains and enjoys a refreshing, consistent breeze year-round. It is an ideal setting for tranquil living or a profitable rental project. Located in a peaceful and scenic area, this lot already has access to water and electricity, allowing you to move straight into the permitting and construction phase. With R-G zoning, the property offers multiple possibilities such as single-family residence, multi-family development, short-term rental including Airbnb (subject to municipal and Planning Board regulations), and potential for small-scale agricultural or limited commercial uses based on permits and local ordinances. Cayey offers many attractions including the charming town center, renowned restaurants like Los Pinos and the famous Lechoneras in Guavate, La Ruta del Lechón, the Cayey campus of the University of Puerto Rico, easy access to expressways leading to San Juan, Caguas, and Ponce, and a cool mountain climate with incredible natural scenery. Opportunities like this do not last long in Cayey. Contact us today to schedule a visit and make your offer before it is too late.

Calle Pineros, Cayey

$89,995

00736 Zip Code

Virtually Staged. Imagine owning nearly two acres of peaceful countryside — approximately 1.9997 cuerdas (~7,859?m² / 84,600?sq?ft) — nestled in the lush mountains of Cercadillo, Cayey. With around 30 *cent of the land cleared and the remaining 70 *cent covered in serene forest, this parcel offers a unique canvas for your dream rural retreat. Enjoy breathtaking panoramic views from your own hillside sanctuary with 40 meters of road frontage and a quiet setting just off PR-715 at Km?5.7. Zoned AD?30 *cent / B-Q?70 *cent (rural general), the land supports residential and rural uses, perfect for building a custom home, tiny house, or eco-cabin. The lot is undeveloped, but nearby access to public electricity and private water/gas services makes it a flexible investment. No sanitary or storm sewer systems are present. Access is via a quaint 3-meter-wide asphalt road, and the property is outside FEMA-designated flood zones (Zone X), with no environmental issues reported. Just minutes away, you’ll find some of Cayey’s most iconic natural and cultural attractions — including the Carite Forest Reserve with hiking trails and waterfalls, Charco Azul for swimming in crystal-clear mountain waters, and the famous Lechoneras of Guavate, a culinary hotspot known island-wide. Also nearby are the Plaza Pública de Cayey, Museo de Artes Populares, and easy connections to PR-1 and PR-52 for quick access to Caguas and the southern coast. This property is offered without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin.

PR-715 KM 5.7 Int Cercadillo, Cayey

$2,900,000

00737 Zip Code

Exceptional opportunity to acquire 6.5 acres of R-1 zoned land at the entrance of Cayey, one of Puerto Rico’s most dynamic and strategically located municipalities. Positioned directly next to Hospital Menonita—one of the region’s leading healthcare facilities—this site offers prime visibility and seamless access to the town’s main transit corridors. Cayey is emerging as a major medical and service hub for Puerto Rico’s central region, drawing professionals and patients from Aibonito, Cidra, Caguas, and surrounding towns. As the area continues to grow in population density and infrastructure, the demand for quality housing and support services is rising rapidly. This property is ideally suited for a residential community with complementary commercial components such as medical offices, wellness centers, or a neighborhood retail plaza. The scale, zoning, and location combine to offer outstanding development potential in a municipality poised for continued growth.

Carr 14 Km 71.2, Cayey